Dog Collar vs Dog Harness: Pros and Cons

Vakar Hussain

Walking your dog is one of the most enjoyable moments for any dog owner – but choosing the right tool for it can be overwhelming. There are so many options out there, but the most common dilemma everyone faces is whether to use a collar or a harness.

 

While both of these tools work great, they serve different purposes, and there is no one right answer. If you are still struggling to make your decision, let's discuss the pros and cons of each.

 

What Are Dog Collars?

Dog collars have been around for centuries and are considered the traditional way of controlling dogs during walks and training sessions. They are relatively simple and straightforward, consisting of a loop of material that goes around the dog's neck with an adjustable buckle or clip.

 

However, in recent years, there has been concern about the harm that collars can cause to dogs, especially those who pull or choke on their leashes. Here are some pros and cons of using a dog collar:

 

Pros Of Dog Collars

• Convenience: Dog collars are easy to put on and take off. They are lightweight and don't restrict the dog's movement, which makes them ideal for short walks, training sessions, and everyday use.
• Identification: Many dog collars come with a tag that contains the dog's name, owner's phone number, and other important information that can help reunite lost dogs with their owners. This can be especially useful if your dog gets lost or wanders away from home.
• Affordability: Dog collars are generally less expensive than dog harnesses, which makes them a popular choice for dog owners on a budget.

 

Cons Of Dog Collars

• Choking and Neck Injuries: If your dog pulls on the leash while wearing a collar, it can cause choking and neck injuries. This is especially true for dogs with delicate necks, like toy breeds and brachycephalic breeds.
• Difficulty Controlling Strong Dogs: Collars are not the best option for controlling strong, large-breed dogs that tend to pull. In fact, using a collar to control a strong dog can actually make the problem worse, as it can stimulate the dog's natural reflex to pull harder.
• Tracheal Damage: Collars can cause damage to a dog's trachea if they are used improperly or if the dog pulls too hard on the leash.

 

What Are Dog Harnesses?

Dog harnesses are a type of equipment designed for dogs that wrap around the dog's torso and provide more control than a traditional collar. Harnesses typically come in a variety of styles and materials and are used for a range of purposes, from training to everyday walks. Some harnesses are designed to help dogs who pull on their leash, while others are intended for use during outdoor activities like hiking and running.

 

Harnesses can also be beneficial for dogs with respiratory issues or neck injuries since they distribute pressure more evenly across the dog's body. Overall, dog harnesses can provide a safer and more comfortable experience for both dogs and their owners. Here are some pros and cons of using a dog harness:

 

Pros Of Dog Harnesses

• Comfort: Dog harnesses are designed to be comfortable for dogs to wear. They don't restrict the dog's movement or put pressure on their necks, which can be especially beneficial for dogs with respiratory issues, like brachycephalic breeds.
• Better Control: Harnesses provide better control over your dog than collars do. They are especially useful for controlling strong, large breed dogs that tend to pull on the leash.
• Safety: Harnesses are considered safer than collars because they don't put pressure on a dog's neck or trachea. This can be especially important for dogs that have a history of choking or tracheal damage.
•  

Cons Of Dog Harnesses

• Expense: Dog harnesses are generally more expensive than collars, which can make them less accessible to dog owners on a budget.
• Difficulty Putting On: Some dog owners may find it challenging to put a harness on their dog, especially if the dog is not used to wearing one.
• Potential for Chafing: If a harness is not fitted properly, it can rub against a dog's skin and cause chafing or other skin irritations.

 

Which Is Better— Dog Collar vs. Harness?

When it comes to walking your furry friend, it's important to choose the right gear. The two most popular options are dog collars and harnesses. Each has its own set of advantages and disadvantages, so it's essential to consider your dog's breed, size, and temperament before making a decision.

 

Dog collars are a go-to choice for many pet owners. They're easy to put on and take off, and they come in various sizes, materials, and styles. However, collars can put pressure on your dog's neck and throat, especially if they tend to pull on their leash. This could lead to breathing difficulties, neck injuries, or even choking. Collars may also be less secure than harnesses, making them more prone to slipping off or breaking.

 

On the other hand, harnesses offer several benefits over collars. They distribute the weight evenly across your dog's chest and shoulders, reducing strain on their neck and spine. This is particularly important for breeds with respiratory issues, such as bulldogs or pugs. Harnesses also give you better control over your dog's movements, making them ideal for training or walking in crowded or unfamiliar areas.

 

Ultimately, the choice between a collar and a harness depends on your dog's individual needs and preferences. Consider consulting with your veterinarian or a pet expert to determine which option is best for your furry companion.

 

Wrapping It Up

Dog collars and harnesses provide two different options for controlling your dog. While dog collars are typically less expensive and easier to put on, they can be unsafe for dogs with delicate necks or those that pull on the leash. Dog harnesses, on the other hand, provide better control and safety but may be more expensive and difficult to put on.

 

If you're looking for high-quality equipment for your pup, Oxford Tale is here to help. We offer a range of collars and harnesses designed for comfort, safety, and durability so that you can choose the perfect one for your dog's needs. Shop our collection today and get ready to explore with your furry friend!